Navigating Ethical Complexities of Artificial Intelligence in Civil Justice: A Discourse Analysis

Abstract

Integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI) into civil justice systems has become a complex issue in the legal technology landscape. This study examines AI-driven decision-making's implications on fundamental legal principles, particularly in discretionary punishment within international civil law. By employing rhetorical discourse analysis, the research highlights the importance of critically evaluating AI's influence on fairness, impartiality, and due process. Thematic analysis explores potential benefits and drawbacks of AI in civil justice systems, emphasizing the need to uphold ethical standards and ensure equitable outcomes. Key themes include the impact of AI on international civil law, balancing technological innovation with core legal principles, ethical considerations such as algorithmic bias and transparency, challenges in ensuring fairness and due process, and the need for a thoughtful approach to AI integration. Combining rhetorical discourse and thematic analysis effectively communicates the significance and scope of the study, presenting a compelling argument for examining AI's impact on civil justice systems while balancing innovation and preserving fundamental legal principles.